Keeping Score of The Score

The Wall Street Journal has a weekly section, The Score, which covers “The Business Week in 7 Stocks.”

This week caught my eye since Target (TGT) was the highlighted stock two weeks in a row. Last week, ending November 24th, TGT was down 11%, “as investors focused on rising shipping and labor costs and mounting supply-chain disruptions.”

This week: “The overall strong start to the holiday shopping season pulled up shares of several big-box retailers, including Target’s 2.8%” The second week didn’t reference the first – an odd omission for the set of readers that may take action on these blurbs.

It telegraphs a possible contrarian strategy – going countertrend to the market. Buy on the open Monday stocks that were down. Short on the open stocks that were up. Here is a spreadsheet where I’m going to test this for a while.

All seven stocks reversed direction Nov 24 to Dec 1 WSJ. So did the market, however. Still, 5 of the 7 trades in this strategy outperformed.

(NB, the 2.8% rise the WSJ has today must have been calculated from the Wednesday close, 69.26, not Friday’s close of 67.35. I’m generally not going to double check the WSJ % reports…and generally there won’t be holiday breaks with unusual trading like the Friday after a Thanksgiving.)

 

Nov 24 open Monday close Friday % change reversal? Outper. S&P?
TGT, -11% 68.07 70.96 4.2 y y
GOOGL, -3.8% 1044 1109.65 6.3 y y
Nissan, -5.5% 8.65 8.87 2.5 y n
LOW, -5.7% 88.67 94.37 6.4 y y
LB, -18% 30.32 33.11 9.2 y y
WBA, -2.6% 79.11 84.67 7.0 y y
CVX – 3.4% 114.7 118.97 3.7 y n
SPY (control) 265.78 275.65 3.7

Proudly powered by WordPress
Theme: Esquire by Matthew Buchanan.